Written by
How to compare two motor insurance quotes beyond the premium
Reviewed by
Your price in 2 minutes
Enter your car number to compare plans
Covers your own car
Kiwi Super NCB up to 90%
One Claims Specialist (industry first)
Introduction
When 2 car insurance quotes arrive side by side, most people look at the premium, pick the lower number, and move on. That is an understandable shortcut, but it is also how car owners end up with a lower payout on a claim, a cashless garage that is not where they need it, or a No Claim Bonus that resets when a better structure was available. Comparing car insurance properly takes less than 10 minutes and involves 7 factors, not just 1.
In this blog, we are going to cover what those 7 factors are, how to compare each one without needing to be an insurance expert, how to verify the insurer before you buy, and what a complete comparison checklist looks like in practice.
Keep in mind
The premium is not the most important number in a car insurance comparison, the Insured Declared Value (IDV) is
2 quotes with the same premium can have different IDVs, different optional covers, and different claim mechanics, none of which shows up in a headline price
The Third-Party premium is fixed by IRDAI and is identical across all insurers, the only part of the premium that actually varies between insurers is the Own Damage component
Settlement ratios, garage counts, and star ratings are published numbers that should not be used as the primary comparison metric, the IDV, the optional cover terms, and the claims process are more directly relevant to your specific policy
Every insurer must be registered with IRDAI, the registration number appears on the policy document and is verifiable before you buy
The 7 factors to compare
The premium is only the starting point. To compare two car insurance quotes properly, look at seven factors that can affect the cover you get, what you pay and how the policy works when you need it.
These are:
- Insured Declared Value (IDV)
- Own Damage premium
- Optional cover terms
- Cashless partner garages
- Claims process
- NCB mechanics
- Insurer verification
First, let's look at why the premium alone does not tell you which quote is better.
1. Compare the Insured Declared Value first
The IDV is the maximum amount the insurer will pay if your car is stolen or declared a total loss. It is one of the most important figures to check when comparing quotes.
Two quotes with the same premium can have different IDVs. A lower IDV can mean a lower premium, but also a lower maximum payout if your car is stolen or declared a total loss.
How to compare IDVs
- Check the IDV shown on each quote.
- Compare it with the current market value of a similar car with the same make, model, variant and year.
- The IDV that reasonably reflects your car's current value is generally the better choice.
- If a lower premium comes with a lower IDV, you are paying less for lower cover, not necessarily getting a better deal.
For cars over 5 years old, there is no fixed IRDAI depreciation schedule. The IDV is agreed between the insurer and the car owner, making it even more important to check whether it reflects the car's current value.
3. Compare what the optional covers actually include
Two policies may offer the same optional covers but provide different levels of protection. For example, Zero Depreciation may have different age limits, eligible parts or claim limits depending on the insurer. Always compare the terms of each cover, not just its name.
For each optional cover in both quotes, check:
Zero Depreciation
Does it apply to all part materials or only some? What is the age limit for the car to be eligible? How many Zero Depriciation claims are permitted per policy year?
Engine Protect
Does it cover water ingress damage from flooding? Does it apply when the car was driven into standing water knowingly? The exclusion conditions vary between insurers and matter significantly in flood-prone cities.
Return to Invoice
Does the payout include road tax and registration charges in addition to the ex-showroom price? Some insurers pay the on-road price in full; others pay only the ex-showroom price.
NCB Protect
Does it protect the No Claim Bonus for 1 claim per year? Does a second claim in the same year still reset the NCB even with the cover active?
Passenger Cover
Is it for named passengers, unnamed passengers, or both? What is the cover limit per passenger?
The same optional cover can work differently across insurers, so do not compare policies based on the cover name alone. Check the specific terms, limits and exclusions in each policy before choosing.
4. Compare the cashless partner garage network in your area
A cashless claim means the insurer pays the repair garage directly, you pay only the compulsory deductible and any excluded items. This only works at a cashless partner garage on the insurer's approved list.
If the nearest cashless partner garage for one insurer is across the city and the other insurer has a network garage near your home or regular route, that is a practical difference that matters at claim time, not at quote time.
How to compare garage networks:
- Check the insurer's cashless partner garage locator for the areas where you park, drive, and are most likely to need a repair, your home, your office, and the routes between them
- Look for a garage that is convenient for you, rather than focusing only on the total number of garages.
- If you prefer an authorised service centre for your car brand, check whether it is part of the insurer's network.
If neither insurer has a convenient cashless partner garage, the comparison shifts to how each handles reimbursement claims, how quickly the claim is reviewed, how easily documents can be submitted, and how responsive the process is.
5. Compare the claims process, not just the settlement ratio
A published claim ratio gives you an overall picture of an insurer's past claims performance, but it does not tell you how your own claim will be handled. When comparing policies, look at the actual claims process and the support available when you need to make a claim.
What to compare in the claims process
How can you register a claim?
Check whether you can raise a claim through an app or website, or whether you need to call customer support and submit documents separately. A simpler process can make it easier to report a claim and track it.
Will you have a dedicated contact?
Check whether you get a specific person to help with your claim or have to speak to different customer support representatives each time you follow up.
How is the inspection handled?
For a cashless claim, the surveyor usually inspects the car at the network garage. For a reimbursement claim, the car may need to be inspected before repairs begin. Check who coordinates the inspection and what you need to do.
How long does the process take?
Check the insurer's stated timelines for claim registration, inspection and processing. You can also review the insurer's grievance process to understand what to do if there is a delay or issue with your claim.
The claims process can have a bigger impact on your experience than a headline claim ratio, so compare how easy it is to register, track and get help with a claim before choosing a policy.
6. Compare what happens to the NCB under each plan
The No Claim Bonus (NCB) is a discount on the OD premium earned for every claim-free year. It is where careful drivers recover a meaningful part of the OD premium over time, and where a single claim can wipe out years of accumulated discount on a standard plan.
When comparing quotes on NCB, consider these:
- Does the plan include NCB Protect as an optional cover? If so, what are the terms, 1 claim protected per year, or more?
- What happens to the NCB if a claim is raised without NCB Protect? Does it reset to zero or step down?
- Does the plan offer any structure that builds a higher NCB over time than the standard IRDAI schedule allows?
The standard No Claim Bonus follows an IRDAI-regulated schedule. Some insurers offer enhanced NCB structures, the terms, conditions, and mechanics of these should be checked in the policy document, not taken at face value from a sales summary.
7. How to verify the insurer before you buy
Every general insurer in India must be registered with IRDAI. Buying from an unregistered entity is both legally invalid and financially unprotected.
Before committing to a quote:
- Check the IRDAI registration number: It should appear on the quote and on the policy document. You can verify it on the IRDAI website
- Check the insurer's published regulatory data: IRDAI publishes comparative data on registered insurers at kiwiinsurance.com/tats-for-gi/, this page aggregates publicly available IRDAI statistics on general insurers in India
- Review the grievance process: Every registered insurer must have a grievance redressal mechanism. Check how complaints are raised and what the escalation path is if a claim is disputed
- Download a specimen policy document: Check kiwiinsurance.com/downloads/ or the insurer's equivalent page to access the policy wording before you buy, not after
The comparison checklist, a quick reference
The following table summarises the 7 factors to consider when comparing 2 or more policies.
What Kiwi Insurance does differently
When comparing car insurance, the OD premium and NCB terms can make a difference to what you pay at renewal. Kiwi Insurance offers features that address both.
Kiwi Super NCB
Only with Kiwi's Super NCB feature, you can build up to 90%, compared with the 50% limit of a standard NCB. This can provide up to 40% more discount than a standard NCB at the same stage of claim-free driving. If you make a claim, your Super NCB moves down by one level instead of resetting to zero.
Dedicated Claims Specialist
Once you register a claim, a dedicated Claims Specialist is assigned to you. They act as your single point of contact and explain the claims process in plain language, so you do not have to repeat your situation to different representatives.
The Claims Specialist is assigned after you register a claim, not when you buy the policy.
Conclusion
A good car insurance comparison goes beyond the headline premium. Check the IDV, OD premium, optional covers, garage network, claims process, NCB terms and insurer details before choosing a policy.
With Kiwi Insurance, Super NCB can help you retain a higher NCB discount, while a dedicated Claims Specialist supports you when you raise a claim.
Written by
Reuben Solomon
Lead Content Writer
Reviewed by
Rupinderjit Singh
Head - Tech Product & Digital Business
Frequently asked questions
Look beyond the premium and check whether the policy provides the right level of cover for your vehicle and how you use it. Compare the IDV, Own Damage cover, optional covers, claims process and other policy terms before choosing.