
Written by

Written by

Reviewed by
Last updated:
Enter your car number to compare plans
Covers your own car
Kiwi Super NCB up to 90%
One Claims Specialist (industry first)
Whether you should claim car insurance or pay out of pocket comes down to one comparison: is the repair cost clearly bigger than your deductible plus what you would lose on your No Claim Bonus. When it is, claiming is usually worth it. When it is not, paying yourself usually protects you better.
By the end, you will have a simple rule you can apply to any repair bill, understand exactly what a claim costs you beyond the garage, and know how Zero Depreciation cover and Kiwi Insurance Super NCB change the calculation.
A claim is worth raising only when the repair cost clearly outweighs your deductible and NCB loss
Standard No Claim Bonus resets fully to zero after one claim, not partially
Compulsory deductible is ₹1,000 for cars up to 1500cc and ₹2,000 above that
A repair cost at or below your deductible gets you nothing from a claim
Kiwi Insurance Super NCB drops only one slab after a claim, never to zero
This decision applies to your own Own Damage claim, not a Third-Party one
Every Own Damage claim has 2 costs attached to it before you see a single rupee back: the compulsory deductible you pay regardless, and whatever happens to your No Claim Bonus (NCB) at your next renewal. A repair that costs only a little more than these 2 numbers combined is barely worth claiming.
The simple version: claim when the repair cost is clearly larger than your deductible plus the value of the NCB you stand to lose. Pay yourself when the repair cost sits close to your deductible, or when protecting several years of accumulated NCB matters more to you than this one repair.
This rule only applies to an Own Damage (OD) claim, raised for damage to your own car. If your car damages someone else's vehicle or property, that is a Third-Party claim, and Third-Party cover is compulsory by law precisely so the other person is not left paying for damage you caused.
You do not get to choose whether a Third-Party claim happens, since it depends on what happened to the other person, not on what is convenient for your premium. The claim or pay out of pocket decision only exists for the Own Damage part of your own policy.
A Third-Party claim also moves differently once it is raised, since it can involve the other person directly or, in a dispute, the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (MACT), rather than a straightforward repair estimate. If you want the fuller picture of how aThird-Party claim actually proceeds, it works very differently from the Own Damage decision this blog covers.
The deductible is the first cost, ₹1,000 for a car up to 1500cc (Maruti Suzuki Swift, Honda City) or ₹2,000 above 1500cc (Hyundai Creta, Kia Seltos). You pay this whether you claim ₹5,000 or ₹50,000, so it is the floor every claim has to clear before it is worth raising at all.
The second cost is what happens to your No Claim Bonus (NCB). NCB is a discount that applies only to your Own Damage premium, rising from 20% after your first claim-free year to a maximum of 50% after 5 claim-free years. Raise a claim, and standard NCB resets fully to zero, not down by one step.
A full reset means you are not just losing this year's discount. You start the climb back from the first claim-free year again, so it can take 5 years of claim-free renewals to get back to where you were before the claim.
This is the part a repair bill does not show you. A repair that looks like a small decision in the moment carries a real cost that includes however many years of a higher Own Damage premium it takes you to rebuild the NCB you had. That is why a repair cost close to your deductible rarely clears the bar.
No Claim Bonus belongs to you, not the car, so this protection carries over if you sell this car and insure a new one. That is one more reason a small claim is worth thinking through properly, since what you protect by paying yourself follows you well beyond this one vehicle.
Zero Depreciation cover is an optional cover that pays a claim in full, with no depreciation deducted on the replaced parts. Without it, the insurer deducts an age-based depreciation amount from the parts bill before paying out, on top of your deductible.
Take a ₹50,000 repair with a ₹2,000 deductible. Without Zero Depreciation cover, the insurer deducts depreciation on the parts first, then pays the balance minus your ₹2,000 deductible, so you receive less than ₹48,000. With Zero Depreciation cover, the only deduction is the ₹2,000 deductible, so you receive closer to the full ₹48,000. The bigger the claim amount, the more this difference tends to matter to the decision.
This matters more as a car gets older, since Insured Declared Value (IDV) depreciation rises from up to 5% in the first 6 months to up to 50% at 4 to 5 years. An older car's parts bill loses more to depreciation without Zero Depreciation cover, which is part of why the same repair cost can be worth claiming on one car and not worth claiming on another.
Add up your deductible and a rough sense of what losing your NCB would cost you over the next few years. If the repair cost is clearly higher than that total, raise the claim. If it is close to or only slightly above your deductible alone, pay for the repair yourself and keep your NCB intact.
Zero Depreciation cover shifts this rule in your favour for bigger claims, since more of a large repair bill comes back to you. It does not change the calculation for a small claim, where the deductible alone is often close to the whole repair cost anyway.
Once you do raise a claim, you register it with the insurer first, and this always happens directly with the insurer, whichever route you bought yourcar insurance through, online, through an agent, or on an aggregator. The insurer then works from the garage's repair estimate rather than one you submit yourself.
From there, the deductible and the depreciation question from earlier both come into play when the claim amount is worked out, and your No Claim Bonus position for the next renewal is set at the same time. None of this changes the decision rule itself. It only confirms that the 2 numbers this blog asks you to weigh, the deductible and the NCB impact, are exactly the 2 numbers the insurer applies on their side too.
Whichever way this decision goes, what happens to your discount afterwards does not have to be as harsh as the standard rule. Kiwi Insurance Super NCB builds up to a 90% discount, which is up to 40% more than standard NCB, and it works differently the moment you do raise a claim.
Deciding whether to claim car insurance or pay out of pocket comes down to comparing the repair cost against your deductible and what you stand to lose on your No Claim Bonus. Claim when the repair clearly outweighs both. Pay yourself when it does not, and remember that the No Claim Bonus you are protecting follows you to your next car too. Kiwi Insurance Super NCB and a dedicated Claims Specialist make that decision less costly either way, whichever one you choose.
"Not sure if your next repair is worth claiming? Head toKiwi Insurance to check prices."
No, not for every scratch or dent. A repair cost close to your compulsory deductible rarely clears what you would also lose on your No Claim Bonus, so paying for small cosmetic repairs yourself usually works out better than raising a claim for them each time they happen.